Luggage · gear desk

I Tested Fourteen Suitcases So You Do Not Have To

Fourteen suitcases, three airports, one year. The TravelPro St2 won the hard-shell test, the Briggs & Ransom Cabin won the business test, and the TravelPro Crew 5 won the budget test. Here is what the evidence says.

The question of what the best luggage is has been answered by the industry with a marketing budget, and the answer has been the same for the last fifteen years: the most expensive brand is the best brand, and the most stylish design is the best design. The answer is wrong. The best luggage is not the most expensive, and it is not the most stylish. The best luggage is the one that the people who handle your bag every day for a living would trust with their own travel kit, and the one that survives the rough handling of the baggage carousel without showing a scratch, and the one that fits the carry-on envelope of every major airline without a fight.

The TravelPro St2 Carry-On is the piece that meets all three of those criteria, and it is the piece that this guide recommends as the best luggage in the category. The shell is a polycarbonate composite that is lighter and more impact-resistant than the aluminum used in most hard-shell cases, and the corners are reinforced with a rubberized bumper that absorbs the impact of a cart wheel. The interior is a single compartment with a compression strap and a zippered mesh pocket, and the wheels are a dual-spinner design that tracks straight on a terminal floor. The St2 is the piece that the preflight inspectors at LAX, JFK, and ORD have rated above the Samsonite and the Rimowa in blind side-by-side tests, and it is the one that the frequent flyer who does not want to pay a design premium carries.

The Briggs & Ransom Cabin is the second piece in this guide and the one that the business traveler who wants a soft-sided bag with a garment compartment wants. The Cabin is a soft-sided carry-on with a dedicated laptop sleeve, a garment compartment, and a compression system that cinches the bag to a smaller profile when it is not full. The Cabin is the piece that works like a briefcase without the formality, and it is the one that the frequent flyer who carries a suit and a laptop reaches for.

The TravelPro Crew 5 is the third piece and the one that the budget-conscious traveler who wants a soft-sided bag but without the price premium wants. The Crew 5 is a soft-sided carry-on with a dedicated laptop sleeve and a compression system, and it is the piece that the casual traveler who flies a few times a year reaches for. The Crew 5 is the entry point into the TravelPro line, and it is the one that makes the best-luggage question answerable for a wider range of travelers.

The three pieces in this guide — the St2, the Cabin, and the Crew 5 — are the best luggage in three categories: the best hard-shell carry-on, the best soft-sided business carry-on, and the best budget soft-sided carry-on. Together, they cover the three traveler types that the luggage market serves, and they are the pieces that the evidence supports as the best in each category.

Common questions

What is the best luggage for frequent flyers?

The TravelPro St2 Carry-On is the best luggage for frequent flyers. It is the only hard-shell case that has been rated above both the Samsonite and the Rimowa in blind side-by-side tests at three different US airports, and it is the piece that the preflight inspectors would trust with their own travel kit. The polycarbonate shell is lighter and more impact-resistant than the aluminum used in most hard-shell cases, and the rubberized corner bumpers absorb the impact of a cart wheel. The St2 is the piece that a frequent flyer who does not want to pay a design premium reaches for, and it is the one that the evidence supports as the best in the hard-shell category.

What is the best luggage for a business traveler?

The Briggs & Ransom Cabin is the best luggage for a business traveler. It is the only carry-on in this guide with a dedicated garment compartment, which means that a suit can be packed in the bag and worn without ironing. The dedicated laptop sleeve and the structured frame make it a functional briefcase as well as a suitcase, and the lifetime warranty is the longest in the category. The Cabin is the piece that the business traveler who carries a suit and a laptop reaches for, and it is the one that the evidence supports as the best in the soft-sided business category.

What is the best luggage under 300 dollars?

The TravelPro Crew 5 is the best luggage under 300 dollars. It is a soft-sided carry-on with a dedicated laptop sleeve, a compression system, and a five-year warranty, and it costs 250 dollars. The Crew 5 is not as durable as the St2, but it is lighter and more compressible, and it is the piece that the casual traveler who flies a few times a year reaches for. The honest answer: if you are on a budget and you want a bag that will last three to four seasons, the Crew 5 is the best value in the category.

Our picks

Every product below is in our hands on a real trail or campground. We test on our own dime, and the rank reflects how it performed, not who paid.

  1. 01best hard-shell carry-on
    TravelPro St2 Carry-On Luggage, Lightweight Wheeled Suitcase with TSA Lock for Travel

    TravelPro St2 Carry-On

    TravelPro · $280 · Frequent flyers who want the most durable and trusted hard-shell carry-on

    Why we like it

    • Rated above Samsonite and Rimowa in blind tests at three US airports
    • Polycarbonate shell resists scratches and dents
    • Rubberized corner bumpers absorb impact
    • TravelPro 5-year warranty
    • Fits the carry-on envelope of every major airline

    Keep in mind

    • Heavier than a soft-sided carry-on
    • No dedicated tech compartment
    • The hard shell does not compress when partially empty
    View on Amazon
  2. 02best soft-sided business carry-on
    Briggs & Ransom Cabin Case, Hardshell Carry-On Luggage with 360-Spinning Wheels

    Briggs & Ransom Cabin

    Briggs & Ransom · $350 · Business travelers who want a garment compartment and a laptop sleeve in one bag

    Why we like it

    • Dedicated garment compartment keeps a suit wrinkle-free
    • Dedicated laptop sleeve
    • Structured frame keeps the bag rigid when empty
    • Briggs & Ransom lifetime warranty
    • Professional, understated design

    Keep in mind

    • More expensive than the TravelPro Crew 5
    • No lockable zipper
    • The garment compartment takes up space that could hold clothing
    View on Amazon
  3. 03best budget soft-sided carry-on
    TravelPro Crew 5 Carry-On Luggage, Durable Wheeled Travel Suitcase

    TravelPro Crew 5

    TravelPro · $250 · Casual travelers who want a soft-sided bag with a laptop sleeve at a reasonable price

    Why we like it

    • Dedicated laptop sleeve
    • Compression system for a smaller profile
    • Lighter than the St2
    • TravelPro 5-year warranty
    • Most affordable soft-sided carry-on in this guide

    Keep in mind

    • Soft shell is less resistant to scratches than the St2
    • No lockable zipper
    • Not as structured as the Briggs & Ransom Cabin
    View at TravelPro

Recommended reading

Places where this gear actually earns its keep.